PHIL339 Bertrand Russell: Ethics, Logic, Pacifism and Truth (Advanced)

Themes from the thought of Bertrand Russell: the basis of ethics, truth, reality, the foundations of mathematics, the external world, logic, paradox, democracy, capitalism, socialism, communism, war and peace.

This paper addresses a range of issues in ethics, philosophy and politics via a critical engagement with thought of Bertrand Russell (1872-1970). Russell was perhaps the greatest philosopher and one of the greatest logicians of the 20th century, but also a political thinker, a public intellectual and an activist, who was twice imprisoned for his anti-war activities. He was one of the founding fathers of analytic philosophy, one of the co-inventors of symbolic logic and a noted philosopher of mathematics, specifically a proponent of logicism, the thesis that mathematics reduces to logic. He defended the correspondence theory of truth against pragmatists such as William James who thought that truth is what pays and Hegelians such as Harold Joachim who argued the truth consists in coherence. He was interested in our knowledge of the external world, at first reducing physical objects to logical fictions and then redefining them as inferred entities.

Under the influence of G.E. Moore, he began as a believer in the objectivity of ethics but subsequently became a pioneer of both emotivism (moral judgments are neither true nor false) and the error theory (moral judgments are all false). He was philosopher of science, writing about the nature of science as intellectual enterprise and its impact on society and culture. In addition to all this he was an advocate of utilitarianism, a critic of Marxism, an analyst of power, a champion of democracy (especially votes for women), a proponent of socialism, a pacifist during World War I, and a campaigner against both nuclear weapons and the Vietnam War. His books on these and related topics (he wrote over seventy) remain in print, sometimes after more than a century.

In this paper we grapple not only with abstract problems such as the nature of value, the nature of truth and the foundations of mathematics, but also with the issues of war and peace, democracy and capitalism, socialism and communism - on all of which Russell had something to say.|

Paper title	Bertrand Russell: Ethics, Logic, Pacifism and Truth (Advanced)
Paper code	PHIL339
Subject	Philosophy
EFTS	0.15
Points	18 points
Teaching period	Not offered in 2021 (On campus)
Domestic Tuition Fees (NZD)	$913.95
International Tuition Fees (NZD)	$4,073.40

^ Top of page

Prerequisite

One 200-level PHIL paper

Restriction

PHIL 221, PHIL 239, PHIL 321

Schedule C

Arts and Music

Eligibility

This is a second-year paper targeted especially at students of Philosophy and students majoring in Philosophy, Politics and Economics (PHPE). Thus the typical student will have met the normal prerequisite for a 200-level PHIL or PHPE paper.

PHIL 105 would be useful (but not essential) as preparation, as would PHIL 222.

Contact

charles.pigden@otago.ac.nz

Teaching staff

Associate Professor Charles Pigden

Paper Structure

Week 1

1. General Introduction and Historical Background . Russell's Life and Works
2. Sidgwick , Russell and the 'Dualism of Practical Reason'. (Is it always rational to do the right thing?)

Week 2
Russell's Critique of Marxism

Week 3

1. The Nature of Truth:
   Analytic correspondence versus Hegelian coherence
2. The Democratic Ideal and Votes for Women:
   Russell's arguments for and against democracy, Edwardian and otherwise

Week 4
Russell, Moore and Metaethics:
Russell, G.E Moore and the 'Naturalistic Fallacy'. Russell versus Moore: two Kinds of Consequentialism.

Week 5
Logic, Existence and Definite Descriptions:
Non-existent entities, especially the present King of France.

Week 6
Russell versus the Pragmatists:

1. Is it OK to believe in God even if the evidence does not support this belief?
2. Is Truth what it pays to believe?

Week 7
Logicism, Paradox and Type Theory:
Can mathematics be reduced to logic?
Russell's Paradox and what to do about it.

Week 8

1. Against World War I:
   Russell's Consequentialist Pacifism.
2. Capitalism and Socialism:
   Russell's Critique of Capitalism and the Case for Guild Socialism.

Week 9
Logical Atomism:
Are physical objects logical constructions out sense-data? Logical constructions versus inferred entities. Do negative truths require negative facts (such as absences or lacks)? Causality Dismissed.

Week 10
Non-cognitivism and the Error Theory:
Russell's Arguments Against Objectivism. Emotivism versus the Error Theory. Non-cognitivism and moral commitment.

Week 11

1. Russell's (structural) Scientific Realism:
   Inferred Entities rather than Logical Constructions. Non-Deductive Inference. Empiricism Modified. Causality Reinstated. How to talk about the External World.
2. Paradox and the Aftermath of Principia:
   Ramsey versus Russell. Logical and Semantic paradoxes. Tarski versus the Ramified Theory of Types. Theories of meaninglessness versus paraconsistent logic.

Week 12

1. Russell's Critique of Bolshevism:
   Critical analysis of Russell's 'The Practice and Theory of Bolshevism'.
2. Problems of War and Peace:
   'I set out with a belief that love, free and courageous, could conquer the world without fighting. I came to support a bitter and terrible war'. Russell's response to the Rise of Nazism

Week 13

1. Nuclear Weapons and World Government:
   Critical analysis of Russell's 'Man's Peril' and 'Common Sense and Nuclear Warfare'.
2. The Retreat From Pythagoras:
   'I sought to understand the Pythagorean power by which number held sway above the flux'. But Russell subsequently came to doubt whether numbers had any such powers since numbers themselves were logical fictions and mathematical truths tautologies. Was Russell right to retreat from Pythagoras?

|

Teaching Arrangements

Teaching
Two 2-hour lecture/seminars per week. Typically we kick off with a short presentation by one of the students; I give an impromptu lecture on the themes raised in the presentation, which broadens out via Q and A into a lecturer-led discussion of the issues.

Assessment
At least one essay must be on one of the more logical topics.

• Class Presentation: 3% of final grade
• First Essay (1,500-2,500 words): 30% of final grade
• Second Essay (1,500-2,500 words): 30% of final grade
• Third Essay (2,000-3,000 words): 37% of final grade
• No Exam

Textbooks

• Pigden, Charles: Coursebook 239/339: Bertrand Russell: Ethics, Logic, Pacifism and Truth (Required). Available in print and on Blackboard.
• Ongley, John and Carey, Rosalind (2013) Russell: a Guide to the Perplexed, London and New York, Bloomsbury (Recommended).
• Russell, Bertrand (1999) Russell on Ethics, ed. Charles Pigden London, Routledge (Recommended).
• Numerous works of Russell's available either in the Library or online.

Graduate Attributes Emphasised

Global perspective, Interdisciplinary perspective, Lifelong learning, Scholarship, Communication, Critical thinking, Ethics, Environmental literacy, Information literacy, Research, Teamwork.
View more information about Otago's graduate attributes.

Learning Outcomes

Students who successfully complete PHIL 239 will acquire:

• A critical understanding of the work of Bertrand Russell, both as an abstract philosopher and as a social and political thinker.
• A critical understanding of Russell's views on topics of ongoing concern, such as: the basis of ethics, the nature of truth, the foundations of mathematics, our knowledge of the external world, logic, paradox, democracy, capitalism, socialism, war and peace.
• Enhanced logical, analytical, communicative and writing skills.

^ Top of page

Themes from the thought of Bertrand Russell: the basis of ethics, truth, reality, the foundations of mathematics, the external world, logic, paradox, democracy, capitalism, socialism, communism, war and peace.

This paper addresses a range of issues in ethics, philosophy and politics via a critical engagement with the thought of Bertrand Russell (1872-1970). Russell was perhaps the greatest philosopher and one of the greatest logicians of the 20th century, but also a political thinker, a public intellectual and an activist, who was twice imprisoned for his anti-war activities. He was one of the founding fathers of analytic philosophy, one of the co-inventors of symbolic logic and a noted philosopher of mathematics, specifically a proponent of logicism, the thesis that mathematics reduces to logic. He defended the correspondence theory of truth against pragmatists such as William James who thought that truth is what pays and Hegelians such as Harold Joachim who argued the truth consists in coherence. He was interested in our knowledge of the external world, at first reducing physical objects to logical fictions and then redefining them as inferred entities.

Under the influence of G.E. Moore, he began as a believer in the objectivity of ethics but subsequently became a pioneer of both emotivism (moral judgments are neither true nor false) and the error theory (moral judgments are all false). He was philosopher of science, writing about the nature of science as intellectual enterprise and its impact on society and culture. In addition to all this he was an advocate of utilitarianism, a critic of Marxism, an analyst of power, a champion of democracy (especially votes for women), a proponent of socialism, a pacifist during World War I, and a campaigner against both nuclear weapons and the Vietnam War. His books on these and related topics (he wrote over seventy) remain in print, sometimes after more than a century.

In this paper we grapple not only with abstract problems such as the nature of value, the nature of truth and the foundations of mathematics, but also with the issues of war and peace, democracy and capitalism, socialism and communism - on all of which Russell had something to say.

Paper title	Bertrand Russell: Ethics, Logic, Pacifism and Truth (Advanced)
Paper code	PHIL339
Subject	Philosophy
EFTS	0.15
Points	18 points
Teaching period	Semester 2 (On campus)
Domestic Tuition Fees	Tuition Fees for 2022 have not yet been set
International Tuition Fees	Tuition Fees for international students are elsewhere on this website.

^ Top of page

Prerequisite

One 200-level PHIL paper

Restriction

PHIL 221, PHIL 239, PHIL 321

Schedule C

Arts and Music

Contact

charles.pigden@otago.ac.nz

Teaching staff

Associate Professor Charles Pigden

Paper Structure

Week 1

1. General Introduction and Historical Background . Russell's Life and Works
2. Sidgwick , Russell and the "Dualism of Practical Reason". (Is it always rational to do the right thing?)

Week 2
Russell's Critique of Marxism

Week 3

1. The Nature of Truth:
   Analytic correspondence versus Hegelian coherence
2. The Democratic Ideal and Votes for Women:
   Russell's arguments for and against democracy, Edwardian and otherwise

Week 4
Russell, Moore and Metaethics:
Russell, G.E Moore and the "Naturalistic Fallacy". Russell versus Moore: two Kinds of Consequentialism.

Week 5
Logic, Existence and Definite Descriptions:
Non-existent entities, especially the present King of France.

Week 6
Russell versus the Pragmatists:

1. Is it OK to believe in God even if the evidence does not support this belief?
2. Is Truth what it pays to believe?

Week 7
Logicism, Paradox and Type Theory:
Can mathematics be reduced to logic?
Russell's Paradox and what to do about it.

Week 8

1. Against World War I:
   Russell's Consequentialist Pacifism.
2. Capitalism and Socialism:
   Russell's Critique of Capitalism and the Case for Guild Socialism.

Week 9
Logical Atomism:
Are physical objects logical constructions out sense-data? Logical constructions versus inferred entities. Do negative truths require negative facts (such as absences or lacks)? Causality Dismissed.

Week 10
Non-cognitivism and the Error Theory:
Russell's Arguments Against Objectivism. Emotivism versus the Error Theory. Non-cognitivism and moral commitment.

Week 11

1. Russell's (structural) Scientific Realism:
   Inferred Entities rather than Logical Constructions. Non-Deductive Inference. Empiricism Modified. Causality Reinstated. How to talk about the External World.
2. Paradox and the Aftermath of Principia:
   Ramsey versus Russell. Logical and Semantic paradoxes. Tarski versus the Ramified Theory of Types. Theories of meaninglessness versus paraconsistent logic.

Week 12

1. Russell's Critique of Bolshevism:
   Critical analysis of Russell's "The Practice and Theory of Bolshevism".
2. Problems of War and Peace:
   "I set out with a belief that love, free and courageous, could conquer the world without fighting. I came to support a bitter and terrible war". Russell's response to the Rise of Nazism

Week 13

1. Nuclear Weapons and World Government:
   Critical analysis of Russell's "Man's Peril" and "Common Sense and Nuclear Warfare".
2. The Retreat From Pythagoras:
   "I sought to understand the Pythagorean power by which number held sway above the flux". But Russell subsequently came to doubt whether numbers had any such powers since numbers themselves were logical fictions and mathematical truths tautologies. Was Russell right to retreat from Pythagoras?

Teaching Arrangements

Teaching
Two 2-hour lecture/seminars per week. Typically we kick off with a short presentation by one of the students; I give an impromptu lecture on the themes raised in the presentation, which broadens out via Q and A into a lecturer-led discussion of the issues.

Assessment
At least one essay must be on one of the more logical topics.

• Class Presentation: 3% of final grade
• First Essay (1,500-2,500 words): 30% of final grade
• Second Essay (1,500-2,500 words): 30% of final grade
• Third Essay (2,000-3,000 words): 37% of final grade
• No Exam

Textbooks

• Pigden, Charles: Coursebook 239/339: Bertrand Russell: Ethics, Logic, Pacifism and Truth (Required). Available in print and on Blackboard.
• Ongley, John and Carey, Rosalind (2013) Russell: a Guide to the Perplexed, London and New York, Bloomsbury (Recommended).
• Russell, Bertrand (1999) Russell on Ethics, ed. Charles Pigden London, Routledge (Recommended).
• Numerous works of Russell's available either in the Library or online.

Graduate Attributes Emphasised

Global perspective, Interdisciplinary perspective, Lifelong learning, Scholarship, Communication, Critical thinking, Ethics, Environmental literacy, Information literacy, Research, Teamwork.
View more information about Otago's graduate attributes.

Learning Outcomes

Students who successfully complete PHIL 239 will acquire:

• A critical understanding of the work of Bertrand Russell, both as an abstract philosopher and as a social and political thinker
• A critical understanding of Russell's views on topics of ongoing concern, such as: the basis of ethics, the nature of truth, the foundations of mathematics, our knowledge of the external world, logic, paradox, democracy, capitalism, socialism, war and peace
• Enhanced logical, analytical, communicative and writing skills

^ Top of page