An Answer to Master Smyth

"W. G." [Gray, William]

TextBaseEarlyTudorEnglish
WGAMS12206a.3
2008
STC 12206a.3
Ringler 12206a.3 and TP 2216. Rpt. Ernest W. Dormer, _Gray of Reading_ (Reading, 1923), pp. 91-4. A contribution to the Gray-Smyth flyting. Single sheet folio, printed on both sides. UMI microfilm reel 1861

An answere to maister Smyth
London: [Richard Lant for] Richard Bankes, sold by John Turke,[1540].



Composition Date: c. 1540 [STC].







folio: 1

An answere to maister Smyth seruaunt to the kynges most royall maiestye. And clerke of the Quenes graces counsell / though most vnworthy.

¶Whether ye trolle in or els trolle out
Ye trolle vntruly / loke better about.

WHere-as of late two thinges ye parused
Concerning the treason of Thomas_Crumwell
Undoutedly both your wyt and your syght were confused
Lackyng a medecyne / blyndnesse to expell
5 Put on your spectacles and marke it well
Than shall you se / and say / maugre your hart
That trolle_in / hath played a true subiectes part

For where-as trolle_a_way (as ye say) tolde trouth
Declaring the offences / wherin Crumwell offended
10 It was not the thyng / wherwith troll_in was wroth
For in that poynt / Troll_in / Troll_away commended
But this was the mater / wherfore they contended
Trolle_away / vnder pretence of trollyng against treason
Practised proude popery / as appereth by reason.

15 And ye supporting the same / your pen runneth at large
Boldly as blynde bayerd / ye write in his defence
And in your myscheuous maner / ye lay falsly to my charge
Sayeng / who that craftely coloureth any others offence
Of lykelyhode in his owne hert / hath the same pretence
20 But here ye speke of lykelyhode / and so blyndly go by gesse
Your fondnesse is the folyssher / and my faute is the lesse.

¶An horse beyng nothing galled / of force ye may make to kycke
With spurryng and with prickinge / more than reason wolde requyre
But if the horse were lustye / coragious and also quycke
25 Ye might be the fyrst perchaunce / that might lye in the myre
As wyse as ye / haue ben drowned in their owne desyre
Many a man / anothers mischefe / of malyce wyll prepare
And yet him-selfe the fyrst / that is caught in the snare.

¶Bycause of making stryfe (ye say) ye wyll take neither parte
30 But here ye breke promyse / for agaynst all reason and r[i]ght right] rtght 1540
Speking with your mouth / that you thinke not with your harte
Agaynst trolle_in / ye take trolle_awayes parte / with all your myght
Thus all thinges lyghtly that ye make / amonge them-selues do fyght
Wherfore whatsoeuer ye write or saye / gretly it shall not skyll
35 For if ye speke any-thing wysely / I thinke it be agaynst your wyll. Ve illi per quem scandalum uenit, Luce .xvij.

¶But blyndly haue ye sclaundred me / good maister Thomas_Smyth
Scraping togither scriptures / your madnesse to mayntayne
Truly your rude rowsty reason / being so farre from the pyth
Had nede of suche a cloke / to kepe it from the rayne
40 For all the worlde may perceyue / how falsly ye forge and fayne
Yet styll you affyrme your falshed / as though ye knew thinges presysely
Christes blessyng on your hert / forsoth ye haue done full wysely.

¶Ye rumble amonge the scryptures / as one that were halfe mad
Wrestyng and writhyng them / accordyng to your owne purpose
45 Facyonyng and framyng them / to your sayenges good and bad
Lyke as the holy Papystes / were wont to paynt their popysshe glose
Do ye take the holy scripture to be lyke a shypmans hose?
Nay nay / although a shypmans hose / wyll serue all sortes of legges
Yet Christes holy scrypture / wyll serue no rotten dregges.

folio: 1v
50 Counsell with some tayler / whan that ye wryte nexte
Take measure of diuinyte / before ye cut the facyon
So shall ye square your scryptures / and the better trym your texte
And than shall men of lernyng / commende your operacyon
But howe shulde he be connyng / that knoweth not his occupacyon
55 Howe shuld a cobler cut a cote / or a smyth tast good wyne
Or how shulde you scarsely a clerke / be nowe a good deuyne?

What lyuyng man (excepte it were you) beynge in his right wyttes
Wolde write as ye haue written / and all not worth a myte
I thinke it be some peuysshe pange / that cometh ouer your hert by fyttes
60 Under the coloure of charyte / to worke your cruell spyte
If men wolde marke your madnesse / and beholde your deuelyssh delyte
Shuld se how ye wrest the scriptures to your sayeng / not worth .ii. chippes
And ioyne them all togither / as iust as Germans lyppes.

¶Whan ye haue spytte your poyson / and sayde euen the worst ye can
65 Than come ye in with charite / wyllyng all stryfe to cease
But surely good maister Smyth / ye speke lyke a mery man
Moche lyke a comen pyke-quarell / that stryfe wolde encrease
Continually cryeng in frayes / holde / kepe the kynges pease
But those be prety peace-makers / in-dede for euery daye
70 That styll bestowe mo strokes / than they that began the fraye.

What wyse man wolde not laugh / for to here you bragge and boste
Of your name / your seruyce / of your offyce and all this gere
As though ye were prymrose-perelesse / and a ruler of the roste
By the declaryng wherof / ye thinke to put pore men in fere
75 But your braggyng and your bostyng / shall neyther be here nor there
As longe as I may indifferently / be suffred to vse my pen
Ye shall neuer be able to face me out / with a carde of ten. Qui [s]e laudat stercore coronabitur, se] fe 1540se] fe 1540

A wyse man wolde haue praysed god / and than prayed for the kyng
The which of their gret goodnesse / to your offyce dyd you call
80 And not to haue bragged therof / and than put it out in printyng
For ye stande not yet so sure / but it is possyble ye may fall
And though your offyce be great / I trust your power be but small
Or els parchaunce ye wold quickly thurst a poore man among the thornes thurst: =thrust
But god almyghty prouydeth well to sende a shrewde cow short hornes.

85 Christ preserue the kynges most noble grace / and sende him longe lyfe
Euen Henry the eight (next vnder god) of this church / the hed supreme
Christ preserue and kepe quene Katheryn / his most lawfull wyfe
Christ preserue Prince Edwarde / the very right heyre of this realme
Christ styll ensence their noble counsell / with the influence of heauen ensence: "inform"; see OED s.v. insense
90 Christ for his tendre mercy / amende all-thing that is a_mys
Christ sende maister Smyth more charite / whan his good pleasure is.

¶Amen.

By me a poore man whose herte if ye knewe
Wolde be the kynges seruaunt as fayne as you.
W._G.
set at the end of the first line of the above couplet

¶Imprinted at London by me Rychard_Bankes / And be to be solde in Pater_noster_rowe by Iohnn_Turke / at the sygne of the Rose.
Cum priuilegio ad imprimendum solum.
This line was set by the printer as part of the colophon