An Answer to a Papisticall Exhortation

Bale, John?

TextBaseEarlyTudorEnglish
JBPap1274a
2008
STC 1274a
Ringler 1274a; TP 379 ('Euerye pylde pedlar...'); and TP 1170 ('My mynde can not ...'), the original "Exhortation", an attack on Dr. Robert Barnes, burned 1540, which Bale reprints (in blackletter) and answers here (in roman font). Rpt. W. C. Hazlitt, ed. for Henry Huth, _Fugitive Tracts Written in Verse_, 1st series, 1875, no. 17. UMI microfilm reel 22

An answere to a papystycall exhortacyon, pretendynge to auoyde false doctryne
Antwerp: S. Mierdman,c. 1548.



Composition Date: 1548?.







sig: [A1]
¶An answere to a papystycall exhortacyon, pretendynge to auoyde false doctryne, vnder that colour to maynteyne the same.

¶By ther frutes shall ye knowe them. Math .7.
sig: [A1v] [leaf blank]
sig: A2
EVerye pylde pedlar
Wyll be a medlar
Though ther wyttes be drowsye
And ther lernynge lowsye
5 Ther meters all mangye
Rashe, rurall, and grangye
Yet wyll they forwarde halte
As menne mased in malte

These vyle cannell-rakers
10 Are now becumme makers
Ther poems out they dashe
With all ther swyber-swashe swyber-swashe: see OED s.v. swiber-, slibber-
Ther darnell and ther chaffe
Ther swylle and swynyshe draffe
15 Soche pype soche melodye
Soche bagge soche beggerye.

Of pylde popyshe facyons
They strowe exhortacions
The people to infecte.
20 With the sedes of ther secte
Pretendynge to dyffyne
Agaynst the false doctryne
But soche dyrtye geare
Ded menne neuer heare.

25 They teache nat in meter
With Paule Iohan and Peter
The worlde to edyfye
With goddes worde christenlye
But scripturs they depraue
sig: A2v
30 As madde-men that do raue
They daunce with the deuyll
To magnyfye ther euyll

They drysle forth a dramme
As he that to Christ camme
35 To trappe hym in a snare
Forsoth it is fonde ware
Let christen menne take hede
Vnto ther wycked sede
For they seke for to blynde
40 The syllye symple mynde,

The papystes tytle. An exhortacyon to auoyde false doctryne.


The papyste.

My mynde can not perfyghtelye endyte
Neyther my penne can trewlye wryte
As my hart doth desyre.
The cause onlye is for lacke of syght
5 In lernynge that is so perfyght and bryght
Wherfore pardon of good men I requyre.


The chrystiane.

sig: A3
Your penne and your mynde
Are both of one kynde
And fyt for soche an hart
10 As owle in the nyght
Without gostly syght
Ye playe a knauyshe part.
Attendite a falsis prophetis qui veniunt ad vos. Math .7

Of soche wolues beware
15 As laye forth a snare
Of outwarde holynes.
Queritis interficere hominem qui veritatem locutus. Iohan .8.
For they do nat elles
But playe the rebelles
20 Agaynst goddes ryghteousnes.


The papyste.

If any man els be greued with thys
Let them take it euen as it is
And I praye God them to amende
I thynke with charyte them to tell
25 As I fynde written in the gospell
To the lawe of God we shuld attende.


The chrystiane.

Lyke a braynyshe dolte
Ye shote forth your bolte
As bolde as bayarde blynde
30 Ye loue the gospell
As the deuyll of hell
Here-after we shall it fynde
Attendite popule meus legem meam. Psal .77

Attende to goddes lawe
35 And to hys worde drawe
sig: [A3v]
All you that faythfull be
Cauete a fermento Phariseorum quid est hipo. Luc .12.
The leuen eschewe
Of pharisees vntrewe
40 Yf ye loue the veryte.


The papyste.

Some of late with them-selues perswaded
Out of the shalowe so fayre they waded
That they felt no grounde.
They had thought vs to haue blynded
45 And of the trewth vs to haue wynded
But now ther deceytes be founde.


The chrystiane.

If people be yll
They shall be so styll
For ought that ye brynge here
50 Your doctryne is chaffe
Your ryme dyrtye draffe
It is vnsauerye gere.
Linguis suis dolose agebant, iudica illos. Rom .3.

The language of lyes
55 A false harlot tryes
To seke a wycked praye.
Sicut nouacula acuta fecisti dolum. Psa .51.
With colours to carpe
As a rasour sharpe
60 To wype goddes treuth awaye.


The papyste.

Let no manne be so styffe-necked
To thinke him-self so hyghly in lerning decked
Standynge in hys owne conceyte.
For yf thou or he be in the wronge
sig: A4
65 Thou nor he can not be so stronge
But the deuyll for the hath a beyte.


The chrystiane.

Stande you where ye lyst
Ye are a papyst
In lernynge verye basse
70 To cum for refuge
To soche a pylde iuge
Is for to seke an asse.
Si lumen quod in te est tenebre sint. Math 6.

Your myndes are so darke
75 Ye seke but the barke
And therin ye remayne.
Velamen positum est super cor eorum. 2. cor .3.
Ye holde fast the letter
And wyll haue no better
80 The spyryt ye do dysdayne.


The papyste.

Ther were heretykes that neuer wolde cease
But from vs to take vnyte and peace
So amonge vs they dyd fyght.
In ther blyndenes so farre gone they were
85 That of God they had no dought or fere.
All to destruccion was ther delyght.


The chrystiane.

Is ther one alyue
Which canne ye depryue
Of that ye neuer hadde?
90 Of stryfe and debate
Sedicion and hate
Your kynde was euer gladde.
Contritio et infelicitas in vijs eorum. Psal .9.

sig: [A4v]
Ye labour and speake
95 To destroye and breake
The vyneyarde of the lorde
Vinea domini exercituum domus Israel est. Esa .5.
Of the losse therof
Ye make but a scof but] a but 1548
100 As Esaye doth recorde.


The papyste.

Christ wylleth vs to take good hede
Of these seducers for we had nede
Loke the scripture and se.
From ther folowers let vs refrayne
105 For small charyte in them remayne
As semeth vnto me.


The chrystiane.

Your-self is the sede
Of deceytfull wede
As your frutes doth report
110 For lesse charyte
In men can not be
Than in your popyshe sort.
Nemo vos seducat inanibus verbis. Eph .5.

The false craftye spyes
115 Come in with ther lyes
All men of them beware
Venit hora, vt omnis qui interficit vos. Ioh .16.
They haue not ther fylle
Tyll they slee and kylle
120 No innocentes they spare.


The papyste.

And a man agaynst them wryte or speke
Some ther be wyll hym cruelly intrete
sig: [A5]
I maruele they are so bolde
Ther was a thynge made of late
125 Some had indignacion therate
And openly beganne to scolde.


The chrystiane.

Whan we fynde ye bolde
In your poperye olde
Therof we do ye telle
130 Your poetes we touche
For shakynge ther pouche
And shewe wherof they smelle.
Imitantur illum, qui sunt ex parte illius. Sap .2.

They folowe the deuyll
135 Which seke to do euyll
And are vpon hys syde.
Vos ex patre diabolo estis, et opera. Iohan 8.
The proude papystes all
With the prestes of ball
140 Do take hym for ther gyde.


The papyste.

But trewly it shall not a whyt skylle
Let them bable euen ther fylle
It is so hote it maye not abyde.
For an heretyke wyll they defende
145 By the kynges lawes iustly condempne[d] condempned] condempne 1548
And saye a christen man he dyed.


The chrystiane.

Who are more bablars
And fra[n]tycke fablars
Than pratlynge papystes be?
150 We knowe none heretykes
Nor trayterous scysmatykes
sig: [A5v]
But your affinite.
Nunquid potest homo ignem abscondere in sinu? Prou .6.

The bosome hath fyre
155 Of fleshly desyre
Where spirituall fathers be.
Masculi relicto naturali vsu femine exarserunt. Rom .1.
With conscience aduste
They burne in ther luste
160 And worke moche vanyte.


The papyste.

Some be afrayed hys confession to shew openly
In prynte they wyll nat haue it verely
The cause ones knowne.
To hys part them-selues somwhat bent
165 Now they fere they shall be shent
Soche gostlye sedes had they sowne.


The chrystiane.

Ye geue dyrte for flynte
The thynge is in prynte
That ye gruge at so sore
170 It is nat vnknowne
What sedes ye haue sowne
In thys realme here-tofore.
Quod timet impius, veniet super eum, Pro .10.

That the wycked dought
175 Shall lyght on ther snought
Ther churche must haue a fall.
Omnis plantatio quam non plantauit pater. Math .15
What God hath not sowne
Nor the gospell knowne
180 Shall be turned ouer-all.


The papyste.

sig: [A6]
Wo be to them that fayne so outwarde
And be so pestylent enuyous inwarde
To a graue maye I lyke them in-dede.
That is without set full of goodly stones
185 Within full of stynkynge rotten bones
Loke the gospell and rede.


The christiane.

Lyke thefe, ratte, and mouse
The poore wydowes house
Your bellyes doth deuoure
190 Ye sucke vppe the fatte
For straynynge a gnatte
In your vsurped poure.
Ve vobis, quia similes estis sepulcris dealbatis. Mat .23.

Who are the whyght graues
195 But soche romyshe knaues
And paynted hypocrytes.
Audite verbum domini principes sodomorum, Esa .1.
As vnder pretence
Of chaste contynence
200 Do playe the sodomytes.


The papyste.

They that be full of iniquyte
Shall neuer com in christes companye
Except they do amende.
God commaundeth those people to walke
205 That agaynst men maliciouslye do talke
And with peace do contende.


The chrystiane.

If Christe do refuse
All soche as abuse
The glorye of hys name
sig: [A6v]
210 Ye chaplaynes of ball
Must nedes haue a fall
And come to vtter shame
Discedite a me omnes qui operamini iniquitatem. Math .7

Ye lobbryshe lurkars
215 And ydle workars
Hence fro me, sayth the lorde
Frustra me colunt docentes doctrinas. Marc .7
Your owne wayes ye vse
And my lawes refuse
220 Lyke as your frutes recorde.


The papyste.

Some heretykes of late as I thynke
Wer lothe that ther flesh shuld stynke
Aboue the erthe or within
They loked euer and hoped for a daye
225 But they were brent all thre by the waye
And taken in ther owne gynne.


The christiane.

At traytours ye wynke
Nat felynge ther stynke
So many as hath bene
230 For a daye they wrought
Whan ye no lesse thought
Ye maye knowe what I mene.
In insidijs suis capiuntur inique etc, Pro .10.

In your popyshe maske
235 The grande captayne aske
Was trapped in hys turne
Durum est tibi contra stimulum calcitra[re] calcitrare] calcitra 1548. act .9.
Ye maye se by thys
What daunger it is
sig: [A7]
240 Agaynst goddes trewth to spurne


The papyste.

To speke of good workes it were a shame
They loued not to heare of that name
But sola fides and none other
Ther tonges ranne so moche vpon fayth
245 But ther hartes were farre thens as Crist sayth
Ther lyppes and hartes were farre a_sonder


The chrystiane.

They neuer denyed
Soche workes as fayth tryed
But your apyshe fantasyes
250 Your tunges and your hartes
Paye neyther good partes
In your lattyn memoryes.
Populus hic labijs me honorat cor eorum, Eze .33.

Your labour of lyppes
255 Is so drye as chyppes
God doth it nat esteme.
Vos transgredimini mandatum dei propter Math .15
Ye leaue goddes precepte
To haue your owne kepte
260 Wherein ye do blaspheme.


The papyste.

If thou wylt take the byble-boke
And vpon saynt Iames pystle loke
Ther you shall I trowe se
How fayth is ther trewly applyed
265 And good workes with hym tyed
Se how they do agre.


The chrystiane.

Paule only of fayth
sig: [A7v]
Of workes saynt Iames sayth
God doth vs iustifye
270 Before God fayth thanne
And workes before manne
Concludeth thys controuersye
Fides sine operibus mortua est, Iaco .2.

The workes that you make
275 Trew fayth do not wake
For-why they are but chaffe.
Nolite margaritas ponere ante porcos, Math .7
Goddes worde doth diffyne
That ye are but swyne
280 Ye fede in swylle and draffe.


The papyste.

Yf thou wylt a faythfull christen man be
Loke thou haue fayth, hope, and charyte
And do thou good for yll
Let thy mouthe and thy hart be without enuye
285 That pleaseth God and the kyng let it please the
And hys mynde fulfyll.


The chrystiane.

All one are those thre
And neuer dysgre dysgre: =disagree; see OED s.v. disgree
Wher fayth is roted fast
290 Our lorde God and kynge
Ye haue wayed nothynge
In your olde practyse past.
Time dominum fili mi, et regem Pro .24

My sonne of all-thynge
295 Feare God and thy kynge
Thus Salomon doth saye.
Achitophel contra Dauid consilium dedit. 2. re .17.
sig: [A8]
With achitophell
Ye papystes rebell
300 And all your kynges betraye.


The papyste.

To speke of holy-breade and holy-water
I intende not to medle with that mater
But leaue it as it is
Let vs one for an-other praye
305 With good hope as longe as we maye
That we maye com to heuyns blys


The chrystiane.

Olde hooles do nat cloute
Least ye be spyed oute
But tarrye yet a tyme
310 Heuyn wyll nat be gote
With your psalmes by note
Yt is to hygh to clyme.
Tu domine singulariter in spe constituisti me. Psal .4.

All they hope in vayne
315 That styll do remayne
In the dregges o[f] popyshe lawes. of] op 1548
Sapientia huius mundi stultitia est apud deum 1. cor .3.
Lyue they neuer so longe
Ther fryndes here amonge
320 They shall dye verye dawes.


The papyste.

To praye for them that thys worlde hath past
I thynke surelye we maye not be agast
Loke the scripture yf I lye.
Rede the Machabees softlye thorow-oute
325 And ye shall fynde it no doute
Yf you your dylygence do applye.

sig: [A8v]

The chrystiane.

Where Christ set no waye
For dead men to praye
It canne not them auayle
330 That the Macabees tell
Shall be no gospell
Where other scripturs fayle.
Salubris est cogitatio pro defunctis exorare. 2. ma .12

To make any mone
335 For soules that are gone
It is vnfaythfulnes
Iustorum anime in manu dei sunt. Sapi .3.
For they fele no rodde
In the handes of godde
340 But peace and quyetnes.


The papyste.

I wryte not thys intendynge to preche
Neyther takynge vpon me any man to teche
My lernynge is not mete
But because vnder holy pretence
345 We shuld not hyde these heretykes offence
But treade it vnder our fete.


The christiane.

Ye vtter soche trashe
And pylde haberdashe
As laye longe in your mynde
350 But loke ye styll hyde
All treason and pryde
Of your olde popyshe kynde.
Nouit dominus viam iustorum, et iter impiorum. Psal .1.

All wayes of the iuste
355 The lorde hath discuste
sig: B[1]
The prestes dwell in ther dreames
Dereliquerunt fontem aque viue, et foderunt. Hie .2.
In ther donge they lye
Lyke boores in a stye
360 For mudde they leaue the streames.


The papiste.

They that thynke that barnes was holy
In ther braynes ther is great foly
Iuge other men what they canne
Surely he was by hym-self alone
365 To contende with hym du[r]st not one durst] duest 1548
He was so proper a manne.


The christiane.

As Paule doth recorde
We are of the lorde
To hym we stande or fall
370 Take hede least ye swerue
For he doth reserue
Ryght iugement for ye all
Abhominantur impii eos, qui in recta via sunt. Eccl .29

Ye wycked papystes
375 In your drowsye mystes
Abhorre the symple sort
Quidnam est hoc? que doctrina hec noua Marc .1.
Ye do not regarde
Goddes worde to be harde
380 But geue it yll report.


The papyste.

sig: [B1v]
But yf the deuyll were here and brent
Some wolde hym pyteously lament
In ther hartes they be so kynde
Hys confession shuld be kept as treasure
385 And with some beleued aboue measure
They are now so blynde.


The christiane.

If they take hys part
That scripture peruart
Stande you amonge hys fryndes.
390 A dyrtye beleue
To the blynde ye geue
To recreate ther myndes
Non est in ore eorum veritas, cor eorum vanum. Psal .5.

Your fayth is so weake
395 No treuth can ye speake
But hate all godly wayes
O pastor et idolum derelinquens gregem. Zach .11
Ye robbe christes flocke
And geue them a mocke
400 In all your iuglynge playes.


The papyste,

All yll thoughtes in our hartes let vs eschue
And lyke trew subiectes to our prince contynue
We shall fynde it ease.
To hys pleasure let vs inclyne
405 And not agaynst hys actes to repyne
So God we shall please.


The chrystiane.

sig: B2
The false foxe that gawde
Doth compas some frawde
By hys false fatterynge toyes
410 Dyssemblars vntrewe
Many prynces rewe
Amonge these worldly Ioyes
In cogitatione tua regi non detrahas Eccl .10.

Who doth a kynge hate?
415 But papystes that prate
Agaynst all godlynes
Sacerdotes beliscum suis concubinis in posturam. Dani .14
Bellys dyrtye dyuynes
With ther concubynes
420 Hath wrought all fylthynes.


The papyste.

Ther is not in the worlde so wyde
Set thys lyttle lande asyde
That hath so noble and gentle a kynge.
Wherfore let vs all in one praye
425 Euen to God both nyght and daye
That longe maye he ouer vs be raygnynge.


The chrystiane.

God saue christen kynges
From your practisynges
For myschef ye intende
430 From haters of treuth
Good seldom ensueth
Our prynce the lorde defende
Beata terra, cuius rex nobilis est. Eccl .10.

sig: [B2v]
Happy is that soyle
435 Wher christen men toyle
Vnder a faythfull kynge
Irritum fecistis pactum leui, propter quod. Mal .2.
Where prestys do remayne
And scripture dysdayne
440 It is an heuy thynge.


Finis.

The appendyce or conclusyon.

NO bussarde so blynde
But now speweth hys mynde
Now cometh hagge and tagge
And shaketh out ther bagge
5 They turne out ther trashe
And shew ther haberdashe
Ther pylde pedlarye
And scalde scullerye.

Our olde romyshe ruste
10 Leapeth out of the duste
With a cankred face
All voyde of goddes grace
Thynkynge ones agayne
In Englande to reyne
sig: B3
15 And be hadde in pryce
To maynteyne all vyce.

Ser Iohan now is bolde
In yche place to scolde
Where men do not care
20 For pylde popyshe ware
He doth them accuse
And saye they refuse
The lawes of the lorde
Bryngynge false recorde

25 They haue a new caste
The scripturs to wraste
And wrynge out of frame
To ther vtter shame
From treuth they do swerue
30 Ther purpose to serue
And care not for godde
Nor hys ryghtfull rodde.

Lorde pyte thy flocke
Whome now the prestys mocke
35 Sturre vppe prynces hartes
To stande on ther partes
Least papystes haue powre
Thy lammes to deuowre
Whome vpon the rood
40 Thou boutest with thy blood. Amen.
God saue the kynge.