What are unreported judgments?
- Unreported judgments are those cases heard in courts or tribunals and not published in a series of law reports.
- Judges recommend which cases are to be reported. Some decisions are oral, not written.
- A case may not be reported because it is of little legal interest or significance. However, unreported decisions can be of great relevance to those researching specific areas of law.
Contents of the Judgments Index
This is a listing of unreported decisions acquired by the University of Otago Law Library. The bulk of the decisions are from the Court of Appeal and the High Court. It is not a complete collection of judgments from these or other bodies but the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court holdings should be substantially complete from November 2000.
While these judgments are obtained in an unreported state, they may have subsequently been reported. It is important to check this using Briefcase and Linx before you use the judgment in your research. Even if the case has been reported, we still keep the unreported version.
Dates of Holdings from Court of Appeal and High Court Decisions
(NB: the bulk of this index is comprised of judgments from these courts)
|Court of Appeal||1976 -|
|High Court||1976 -|
Dates of Holdings from other bodies
(NB: holdings for the following are not extensive)
|Complaints Review Tribunal||2001 -|
|District Court||1984 -|
|Employment Court||1992 -2000|
|Employment Tribunal||1993 -1999|
|Family Court||1982 -|
|Maori Appeal Court||1998 -|
|Maori Land Court||1997, 2000|
|Overseas judgments||2001 -|
|Privy Council||1989 -|
|Supreme Court||1956, 1963, 1966, 1968, 1972 -76, 2000-|
|Youth Court||1992 -|
Decisions of the following bodies are not listed in this Index, but are held in a near complete state in the Law Library.
|ACC Appeal Authority||KG/348/A24|
|ACC District Court Appeals||KG/348/A25|
|Broadcasting Standards Authority||KG/348/B7|
|Environment Court / Planning Tribunal||KG/348/N5|
|Film and Literature Board of Review||KG/348/F5|
For further information about the range of courts and tribunals, and the availability of their decisions, refer to the Waikato University Law Library's directory of decisions.
Searching the judgments index
- There is no need to use capital letters for names, or to include 'v' between parties when searching.
- We recommend you search the index using the court file number if you know it.
- The court number is filed in the following format: e.g: AB 111/99. It should be searched by typing in just the number eg: 111/99.
- In the year 2000, the filing system of some court file numbers changed e.g: CP 73-SD/00. Search for this by typing 73-SD/00.
- Courts are recorded in an abbreviated format. For example the Court of Appeal is recorded as CA, the High Court Auckland as HC AK. See the list of abbreviations of courts for more details.
- Judgments dates need to follow a dd/mm/yy format.
Finding judgments in the library
The Library's collection of judgments is divided up into sets. This is an internal filing system unique to the University Law Library. The set number determines the location of the judgment.
- Within each set the cases should be bound more or less alphabetically. There are some errors in the ordering.
- Cases involving the Crown (the Queen) are filed under R v (R = Regina).
- Cases are filed under the surname of the first party. Company names theoretically should be filed under the correct company name e.g: Robert Jones Investment is filed under Ro.
Structure of the sets
- Set 0 are those judgments on order. Ask a staff member when they may be available.
Sets 1-15 are on the open shelves in the New Zealand section at KG/346. They can be read and photocopied in the Library.
Set 16 judgments are those most recently acquired and are held at the Main Desk and may be borrowed for two hours.
Set 17 are judgments which are missing.
Requesting Judgments which are not held by the Law Library
- Judgments can be requested only by Law Faculty staff.
- Please fill in the request form or email the Library with the details of the case.
- Postgraduate and final year honour students need the approval of their supervisor before requesting judgments for their thesis or dissertation.
- A permission slip can be obtained from the Main Desk of the Law Library. This needs to be signed by the supervisor and returned to the Library with the request.
- All other students who wish to obtain judgments can do so by
calling Butterworths on 0800 0800 986. You may pay using a VISA
card or be invoiced in advance.
Citing unreported judgments
The citing of unreported decisions differs from that of reported cases, e.g: Hoiho v Johnstone, Jones & Wilke (High Court, Dunedin CP 53/99, 12 July 1999, Manx J). You need to cite the date of judgment rather than the date of the hearing.
A lettered code is used in older court filing numbers.
- A: Action - old code; is now CP
- AD: Admiralty
- AP: Appeal
- B: Bankruptcy
- CA: Court of Appeal
- CP: Civil Proceeding
- CL: Civil List
- HC: High Court
- M: Miscellaneous
- P: Probate
- S: Sentence
- T: Trial - criminal
Reference: Mulholland, R.D. Introduction to the New Zealand Legal System. Wellington: Butterworths, 1999: 6.48.
Last revised: 8 January, 2013