Department of Bioethics seminar – Determining death: Biological, ethical and social considerations
Much of the debate over whether brain death is death has focused on disagreement over the correct biological account of death, i.e., what it means for any organism to die.
Lizza argues that defining and determining death in the social and legal context cannot be settled by biological considerations alone. Metaphysical considerations about our nature, along with social and ethical considerations about how the brain dead should be treated, are relevant to defining and determining death. Lizza also addresses how disagreement over the criteria for determining death should be managed in the medical and legal contexts.